92% Say a Better Culture Would Make Their Company More Valuable. 16% Say Theirs Is Where It Should Be.

Every CHRO who has tried to fund a culture initiative recognizes the moment the conversation stalls. The CFO rarely argues that culture is unimportant. The CFO argues that nobody has put a number on it that would survive a board meeting. That objection is reasonable, and most of the evidence offered in response deserves it — vendor whitepapers, consultancy surveys, and correlation charts built on self-selected samples.

There is a better place to start. In 2022 the Journal of Financial Economics published “Corporate culture: Evidence from the field,” by John Graham, Jillian Grennan, Campbell Harvey, and Shivaram Rajgopal. It is a finance paper, in a top finance journal, written by finance academics, built on a survey of 1,348 North American firms. A CFO will accept the source. That alone changes the character of the conversation.

What 1,348 Executives Actually Said

The paper reports three numbers that belong together. Over half of the senior executives surveyed rank corporate culture among the top three drivers of firm value. Ninety-two percent believe that improving their culture would increase their firm’s value. And only 16 percent believe their culture is currently where it should be.

Read those in sequence and the shape of the problem appears. This is not a population that needs convincing. It is a population that is already convinced, already believes improvement would pay, and has not delivered the improvement. The gap is not one of belief. It is one of execution.

Be precise about what the 92 percent measures, because a CFO will test it. It is a statement of executive belief about the value of improvement. It is not a measured return, and the paper does not present it as one. Presenting it accurately is what makes the rest of the conversation credible.

The Distinction Where the Gap Lives

The paper’s most useful contribution to a CHRO is not a percentage. It is a definition. The authors treat corporate culture as an informal institution composed of two distinct things: cultural values and cultural norms. A cultural value is an ideal state of behavior — integrity, adaptability, accountability. A cultural norm is the day-to-day living out of that value through typical patterns of conduct.

Effectiveness, in their framework, depends on the alignment between values, norms, and the firm’s formal institutions — its policies, its governance, its pay. Their conclusion is blunt: cultural norms are as important as stated values in achieving success.

That is where the 16 percent lives. Almost no company has a values problem in the sense of having chosen bad values. The published values are nearly always defensible. The gap opens between the values on the wall and the behavior in the workflow — between what a company says it rewards and what it actually rewards on a Tuesday afternoon under deadline.

A second paper sharpens the point. Guiso, Sapienza, and Zingales, writing in the same journal in 2015, examined which dimensions of corporate culture relate to firm performance. Their finding: proclaimed values appear irrelevant. Yet when employees perceive top managers as trustworthy and ethical, firm performance is stronger. Stated values, on their own, carried no observable relationship to results. Perceived integrity did.

The Obstacles the Research Identifies

The Graham et al. paper does not leave the gap unexplained. It documents obstacles that keep culture from being where executives say it should be, and two of them matter more than the rest: inattentive leaders and misaligned incentive compensation.

The leadership finding is the one that tends to shock the room. Nearly one-fifth of respondents indicated that their own senior leadership works against the firm’s culture being effective. These are executives describing their own C-suite. The authors suggest that leadership is itself under pressure from impatient investors and inadequate governance structures — which reframes the problem usefully. This is not a story about bad leaders. It is a story about leaders responding rationally to the system they sit inside.

Guiso, Sapienza, and Zingales found something structurally consistent: publicly traded firms were less able to sustain integrity as a corporate value, and traditional measures of corporate governance did not appear to have much effect on that. The pressure is systemic, and the standard governance apparatus does not neutralize it.

The Obstacle Most Companies Will Not Examine

Of the two, incentive compensation is the one that goes unexamined — and the reason is structural, not intellectual.

Every other culture intervention lives inside HR’s authority. Training, values refreshes, manager enablement, engagement surveys, internal communications: a CHRO can commission all of it without leaving their own budget. Incentive design cannot be touched that way. It belongs to the compensation committee, the CFO, and the board. Naming it as a culture obstacle means telling the people who approve your budget that their pay architecture is part of the problem.

So it does not get named. The organization runs the interventions it controls and leaves untouched the formal institution most likely to be generating the norms it dislikes. If quarterly targets determine variable pay, quarterly behavior becomes the norm — regardless of what the values statement says about long-term thinking. The values did not fail. They were outbid. The executives in the survey say as much: 27% report that incentive compensation focuses employees too much on short-term objectives, and 47% report that it attracts or retains the wrong type of people altogether.

For a CHRO, this is the strongest available argument, precisely because it is uncomfortable. It moves the culture conversation out of the soft-skills category and into the CFO’s own domain. It reframes the ask: not “fund a culture program,” but “let us find out whether our formal incentives are working against our stated strategy.” That is a question a CFO has standing to care about.

What This Research Does Not Say

The fastest way to lose a CFO is to overclaim, so make the limits explicit before the question is asked.

Graham and colleagues established what executives believe. Their survey documents perception, not measured financial return. Guiso, Sapienza, and Zingales established an association between perceived managerial integrity and stronger firm performance — an association, not a demonstrated causal chain running from a culture program to an earnings line.

Neither paper shows that a culture-change initiative produces a financial return. Anyone who cites them that way is misreading them, and a competent CFO will catch it within a sentence. The honest version is more useful anyway: the research establishes that senior executives believe culture is a top-tier value driver, that almost none of them think theirs is working, and that the mechanisms they blame are observable and addressable.

State that yourself, first, before anyone else does. A CHRO who volunteers the limits of their own evidence is far more likely to be believed about the rest of it.

Closing the Gap Starts With Measurement

If the gap sits between stated values and everyday norms, then closing it requires measuring norms. Most organizations do not. They measure engagement, satisfaction, or intent to stay, and they ask employees to rate the stated values back to them — which produces a reading of how well the values are remembered, not how reliably they are practiced.

A measurement approach built for this problem looks different. It asks what behavior actually occurs under pressure, where the deviations cluster, and which formal institutions — pay, promotion, escalation paths, performance review — are reinforcing behavior that contradicts the stated value. It treats the values-to-norms distance as the primary quantity of interest, because that is what the research says determines effectiveness.

That distinction is the whole argument, and it is the reason most culture surveys produce activity rather than insight. We take it up in detail in “Why Your Culture Survey Isn’t Measuring Culture.”

Sixteen percent is not a verdict on any one company. It is a description of a common failure mode — investing in values while leaving norms unexamined and formal incentives unquestioned. The organizations that close the gap are the ones that stop asking whether people believe in the values and start asking what the system actually pays them to do.

Sources

Graham, J. R., Grennan, J., Harvey, C. R., & Rajgopal, S. (2022). Corporate culture: Evidence from the field. Journal of Financial Economics, 146(2), 552–593. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfineco.2022.07.008

Graham, J. R., Harvey, C. R., Popadak, J., & Rajgopal, S. (2017). Corporate Culture: Evidence from the Field. NBER Working Paper No. 23255. https://doi.org/10.3386/w23255 | https://www.nber.org/papers/w23255

Guiso, L., Sapienza, P., & Zingales, L. (2015). The value of corporate culture. Journal of Financial Economics, 117(1), 60–76. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfineco.2014.05.010

Guiso, L., Sapienza, P., & Zingales, L. (2013). The Value of Corporate Culture. NBER Working Paper No. 19557. https://doi.org/10.3386/w19557 | https://www.nber.org/papers/w19557

Columbia Business School (2023, September 7). Not Just Soft Skills: Corporate Culture as a Key Company Value Driver. Research in Brief, adapted from Graham, Grennan, Harvey & Rajgopal. https://business.columbia.edu/research-brief/research-brief/not-just-soft-skills-corporate-culture-key-company-value-driver